Tennessee gets Hokied: Is the SEC an overrated conference?

Posted by By Sports Session at 1 January, at 12 : 57 PM Print

Tennessee gets Hokied: Is the SEC an overrated conference?

The Virginia Tech Hokies defeated the Tennessee Volunteers 37 – 14 in the Chick-fil-A bowl, Virginia Tech was who represents the ACC was ranked while Tennessee out of the SEC was not ranked.  The outcome of this game was a bit of a surprise too many as you could see the disbelief on the faces of Tennessee fans as the game progressed, at some point that perception should change because conferences are more evenly matched today as ever before.

You have heard all too many College Football experts tell you how inferior the ACC is when compared to the SEC, but watching the Chick-fil-A Bowl last night it sure did not seem that way.  Now before you talk about how Virginia Tech was the higher ranked team and they were supposed to win, we all know that.  But its the way in which Virginia Tech dominated Tennessee for most of the game that was impressive.
The experts will tell you that the SEC is a tougher brand of football, and the ACC plays a soft more finesse style of football.  These experts are largely basing this off the fact that the SEC plays great in conference games against each other, but for the most part they are just a bit above average when they play out of conference games against other BCS schools.

From 1998 – 2008 the SEC was 45 – 36 against the ACC (.556 win percentage) I would hardly call that dominating when the two conferences match up.  The SEC did go 5 – 2 this season against the ACC to slightly improve it’s winning percentage, but a 7 – 3 win by South Carolina over NC State, and Virginia Tech played Alabama tougher than Florida this season.  I wouldn’t call any of those performances dominant.

On this night Tennessee looked inferior to Virginia Tech, and coming into the game Tennessee had the SEC’s fourth ranked defense which isn’t bad in a “power” conference.  Virginia Tech made them look almost pedestrian tonight, this is the same defense that held Alabama to 12 points and held Florida to 23 points.  The Hokies easily put up 37 points on the Vols defense, and with a former NFL defensive coordinator running that defense made it all the bit more surprising.

I am not saying that the ACC conference is the cream of the crop over the SEC or anything of that nature, I am simply stating that SEC “dominance” is highly overrated and you can see when they play teams from other BCS conferences the games are fairly competitive.  Sure if Florida played Duke I would expect the game to be a blowout in Florida’s favor, there are always mismatches.

The true gauge is the middle of the conference, if you take out the two best teams and two worst teams in each conference the SEC isn’t going to be much better than the other BCS conferences.  The league just isn’t as tough as everyone makes it out to be, your conference opponents know you best that’s why they game seem tougher.  That is a true fact about every conference, and USC is a perfect example of that fact with their losses to inferior conference opponents seemingly every season.

Yes those in conference games are great, watching Auburn and Alabama go at it is fantastic.  But I can name several ACC, Big Twelve, and Big Ten in conference games that were just as exciting.  The SEC gets the benefit of the doubt at every turn it seems, and I don’t think it’s really warranted.  Yes Florida is/was dominant for the past few years, and Alabama is poised to win a National Title this season.  But after those two teams it’s quite a mediocre conference with every other team boasting at least three loses.

The reason it matters stems from the fact that the pre-season college football rankings always put SEC teams in favorable positions, and it gives them a leg up on BCS bids and opportunities to play in the championship game.  It plays itself out when you have several one loss teams vying for a spot in the BCS title game, and more often than not the benefit of the doubt is given to the SEC schools.

This comes from the perception that schools like Auburn, Tennessee, Georgia, and Arkansas are much better teams than the average school from other conferences.  That just isn’t true anymore of the programs listed none of them have been all that good for the past several years except Georgia.

You commonly hear sportscasters say I would take a one loss SEC school over an undefeated school from another conference.  I don’t understand the logic in that statement, SEC schools have been ducking tough out of conference games for years.  Florida canceled their annual game with Miami years ago, and it has been rumored that several SEC schools turned down offers from Boise State to play them.

I am sure fans of the SEC will find reasons to validate the SEC as being deserving of the consideration they are given by pollsters every year.  If the conference is so dominant why duck tough out of conference games to play teams like Charleston Southern and Memphis?  I don’t think the gap between the SEC and other conferences is as wide as some would like you to think.  Virginia Tech’s performance against Tennessee is further proof of that fact.

College Football Front Page Features , , , , , , , , ,

Related Posts

7 Comments

  1. Brandon Hamblen, 2 years ago Reply

    I originally read this artice on Bleacher Report. I agree with you that the difference between the SEC and the other conferences is not as great as some of us fans of SEC teams think. I do think the SEC is the best conference though.

    • Sports Session, 2 years ago

      Thanks for the comment Brandon. I believe the SEC is the best conference as well, the national titles they have won recently speaks to that heavily. I just feel Notre Dame got the benefit of the doubt too much for many years, and now that mentality has kind of moved to the SEC teams. Even though I love watching SEC games, I can’t help but feel cheated that if a good team from another conference were locked in a race for the National Title and had one loss they would lose the bid to an SEC school with one loss based off of being perceived as a more powerful conference.

  2. gj, 2 years ago Reply

    Hahaha, the sec the dominant conference? give me a break. Idiots have been spreading that around for years because OSU got OUTCOACHED not outplayed by florida and LSU. If they would have kept giving the ball to beanie wells and used the run game in both of those games the outcomes would have been different. Auburn, who almost beat Oklahoma, almost lost to northwestern..hahaha..and LSU was dominated most of the game by Penn State. SEC is NOT the dominant conference, hate to break that to you..nor is the PAC10. If there were playoffs then you would really see that anything can happen. but keep fooling yourselves into thinkint that the sec is the best if it makes you feel good

    • Sports Session, 2 years ago

      I think there is a difference between dominant and “best”, I think top to bottom they are probably the best, although the Big 10 is impressing me right now. I wouldn’t say dominant though, I think it’s changing now most conferences are evenly matched at this point. Who you say is the best?

  3. John, 2 years ago Reply

    There is no way that the SEC is the best conference.. That has already been proven this bowl season..

    • Sports Session, 2 years ago

      The bowl record is a bit eye opening when you look at it.

  4. Brandon Hamblen, 2 years ago Reply

    I agree with you SS. Florida, would have been taken ahead of Boise or Cincy and they were undefeated.

    John, how has that been proven? To date, the SEC is 3-3 in bowl games with four to go.

    gj, most fans of SEC teams want a playoff. Mostly out of arrogance because they believe two SEC teams will end up playing for the title yearly.


Post Your Comment

Recent Comments

SS Favorite Sites